neuralclone: (Spock)
In which we meet the first of a long line of Star Trek aliens with godlike powers--the Thasians.  Unfortunately for the Enterprise, they've gifted some of their powers to an adolescent boy with a short temper, no social skills and a crush on Janice Rand.  (Incidentally, Kirk's advice to Charlie on that subject shows that our womanising captain is on board with the idea of consent.)

"Charlie X" clearly owes a lot to the Twilight Zone episode "It's a Good Life".

(Since The Orville draws so strongly on Star Trek, I wonder when they're going to do an episode involving godlike aliens?)

There's a cute and rather unusual scene where Uhura sings a flirtatious song while Spock accompanies her on his Vulcan lyre.  Apparently it was originally intended to make Spock and Uhura a couple--but the idea was scotched because TPTB wouldn't consider an interracial relationship.  I'm not sure how true this is, but if it is, it means that the Spock/Uhura relationship in J.J. Abrams Trek isn't as far from canon as it first appears!

... I've also been rewatching the first season of The Orville--very slowly, starting with "Old Wounds".  I noticed that at the climax, Isaac looked as amazed as the rest of the crew as Ed and Kelly destroyed a Krill ship with a fast-growing redwood.  I wonder if the thing that made the Kaylons decide to go on a rampage against organic life wasn't Isaac's reports on our dodgy history, but him singing our praises as an ingenious and flexible species?



neuralclone: (Spock)
Since I'm going to be home for a bit, I've decided to rewatch Star Trek TOS.  I wonder how far I'll get?  Anyway, here I am at the very first episode: "The Man Trap".  This was the one that introduced viewers to characters and Star Trek universe.  There's a bit of Early Installment Weirdness, but on the whole the series is already knows what it wants to do.

It begins with a landing party beaming down, and Kirk bantering with McCoy.  ("Is that how you get girls to like you?  You bribe them?") He's already "Bones".  Slightly oddly, "The Man Trap" involves an ex-girlfriend of McCoy's, while in the future we'll mostly see a long parade of Kirk's exes.  (I don't think I'll be spoiling a 54-year old show too badly if I reveal that "Nancy' is actually an alien "salt vampire".)

Spock is already Spock - mostly.  We first see him in charge on the bridge, where Uhura is trying to flirt with him (unsuccessfully)

Uhura: Tell me how your planet Vulcan looks on a late easy evening when the moon is full.
Spock: Vulcan has no moon, Miss Uhura.
Uhura: I'm not surprised, Mr Spock.

However, his "logical" persona comes a bit unstuck at the end of the episode, where he has an extremely emotional outburst.  ("It's killing the captain!")  And as the Vulcan neck pinch has yet to be invented, we see him throwing punches.

The relationship between Kirk, Spock and McCoy is not yet quite there.  Kirk is clearly friends with McCoy, but the snarky banter between Spock and McCoy is not yet in evidence.  There's a germ of a friendship between Kirk and Spock, but their relationship is yet to develop it's relaxed, teasing quality.

Uhura, Janice Rand and Sulu all get decent scenes.  Sulu is hanging out in the botany lab in this episode.  I don't recall if we see him there again.  Is it a characteristic they dropped?  No sign of Scotty in this episode.  All in all, they do a good job of showing us the Enterprise as a working starship with a busy crew.

Oh, and not one, but four redshirts get killed in this episode.  Oddly enough, none of them are wearing red shirts!  However the episode establishes the Star Trek tradition of killing day-players and extras.

August 2022

S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
1415 1617181920
21222324252627
28293031   

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Apr. 23rd, 2025 04:43 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios